Lahore High Court Gets Petition to Ban Smart Glasses

The Lahore High Court is hearing a petition that seeks to ban the unregulated import and sale of smart glasses fitted with cameras and microphones in Pakistan — devices the petitioner says can secretly photograph, record and live-stream people without them ever knowing. Chief Justice Aalia Neelum has summoned the country’s top interior, commerce, tax and customs officials to appear in person at the next hearing on October 15.

The summons came after several government departments failed to submit their replies to the court despite formal notices. The Chief Justice questioned why the remaining respondents had not answered, and directed the Interior Secretary, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) chairman, the Commerce Secretary and the Member of Customs to appear personally.

Key Takeaways

  • The Lahore High Court is hearing a petition seeking a ban on the unregulated sale of camera-equipped smart glasses in Pakistan.
  • The court has summoned the interior and commerce secretaries, the FBR chairman and the member customs to appear in person on October 15.
  • The petitioner argues the glasses violate constitutional privacy protections because they can secretly record people who think they are just looking at ordinary eyewear.

What the Petitioner Is Asking For

The public interest petition — reported in some outlets as filed by citizen Husnainul Abideen through Advocate Shahram Saqi, and in the latest hearing reports as filed by Nadira Bibi — argues that camera-equipped smart glasses, such as the Ray-Ban Meta glasses launched in 2023, pose a direct threat to privacy, dignity and national security.

The central argument is disarmingly simple: the glasses look like ordinary eyewear. Unlike a smartphone held up to record, the wearer can photograph, film or live-stream anyone in their field of view while appearing to do nothing at all. The counsel told the court that this capability distinguishes smart glasses from mobile phones — and violates Articles 9 and 14 of the Constitution, which protect personal liberty, dignity and privacy.

The Demands

The petitioner has asked the court to declare the unrestricted use of such glasses incompatible with the Constitution, and to direct the authorities to:

  • Prohibit the import of camera-equipped smart glasses
  • Review the regulatory approvals issued by the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA)
  • Ban the glasses from courts, airports and government offices
  • Stop customs clearance of relevant consignments
  • Require the cybercrime agency to disclose complaints involving such devices

Sold in Lahore, Never Officially Launched in Pakistan

One of the more striking claims before the court is that the devices are not officially sold by Meta in Pakistan — yet they are openly available through online sellers and physical shops in Lahore, including stores at Hafeez Centre, the city’s well-known electronics market. The counsel also said the glasses are sold in markets and supermarkets, arguing they could be used for covert recording.

That grey-market availability is why customs and the commerce ministry are in the court’s sights: if the devices were never formally cleared for this market, how are consignments entering the country, and who approved them?

Officials in Court — and Missing

At the latest hearing, the deputy director of the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA), Hassan Naqvi, appeared before the court, along with Deputy Attorney General Rafaqat Ali Dogar. The deputy attorney general presented a report on behalf of the NCCIA.

The PTA’s legal adviser, Muhammad Afzal Khan, asked for more time to submit the regulator’s response — a request the court accepted. But the Chief Justice was displeased that other respondents had not replied at all, despite being formally notified, prompting the personal summons of the four senior officials.

A Global Privacy Backlash

The petition leans on foreign precedent. It cites concerns raised by data protection regulators in Ireland, Italy and Germany over camera-equipped glasses, and points to bans on smart glasses in courts in England and Wales and in New York.

The controversy is not unique to Pakistan. Since Meta launched its Ray-Ban smart glasses, there have been multiple reports of the devices being used to film women and girls without consent and share the footage online. In the UK, pubs, major theatres, some schools, the Faslane naval base and even Comic-Con have banned them. Privacy advocates worldwide have warned that AI-powered glasses — which can now identify faces and look up strangers in seconds — cross a line that phone cameras never did.

An Awkward Moment for the Court Itself

The case arrives at a pointed moment for the Lahore High Court itself. Only days before the latest hearing, the High Court banned filming, photography and TikTok videos on its own premises, with phones liable to confiscation. A rule written for handsets is easily defeated by a camera that sits on the bridge of the nose — an irony the court cannot have missed.

What Happens on October 15

The next hearing will be the decisive one for the government’s position. The four summoned officials — covering interior, commerce, tax and customs — are expected to explain, in person, their stance on the sale and import of camera-equipped glasses. The PTA will also have to file its long-delayed response.

Three broad outcomes are possible. The court could order the kind of ban the petitioner wants — though enforcing a ban on a device that slips across borders through grey channels would be a challenge. It could instead order regulation: import controls, registration requirements, mandatory consent indicators, or restricted zones like courts and airports. Or it could accept the government’s replies and leave the current situation in place — though the Chief Justice’s tone so far suggests that is the least likely outcome.

What This Means for Pakistani Consumers

For now, nothing has changed: the glasses remain available. But buyers and sellers should know the legal ground may be shifting. If the court orders customs to stop clearing consignments, grey-market supply could dry up. If restricted zones are imposed, wearing the devices in courts, airports and government offices could become an offence.

More broadly, the case is Pakistan’s first major legal confrontation with the privacy questions posed by AI wearables — and whatever the Lahore High Court decides will set the template for how the country’s institutions handle a technology designed to watch people without being watched back.

The petitioners’ counsel has framed it as a dignity issue: in a country where public and private space blur, where women already face harassment with phone cameras, a device that records while looking like nothing at all changes the equation. The court will decide on October 15 whether the law needs to change with it.