Punjab’s Auqaf Department has demoted the former khateeb of Data Darbar — Lahore’s most revered Sufi shrine — after a departmental inquiry found allegations of financial misconduct, embezzlement and forgery against him to be proven.
According to an Auqaf Department spokesperson, the inquiry against Mufti Muhammad Ramzan Sialvi was conducted under the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability (PEEDA) Act. Along with the demotion, the department ordered the recovery of more than Rs. 2.65 million from the former khateeb.
Key Takeaways
- Punjab’s Auqaf Department demoted former Data Darbar khateeb Mufti Muhammad Ramzan Sialvi after a departmental inquiry found embezzlement and forgery charges proven.
- The department ordered recovery of more than Rs. 2.65 million linked to unauthorised payments during the 2025 Data Darbar Urs.
- The ruling is part of a wider crackdown on donation-box irregularities at the shrine, where two other former officials have also faced penalties.
What the inquiry found
Reports on the case indicate that the recovered amount is linked to payments made during the 2025 Data Darbar Urs and the International Sufism Conference without the required authorisation. The inquiry concluded that the financial misconduct and forgery charges against Sialvi were substantiated. Notably, the department moved only after completing the full PEEDA process: a formal charge sheet, an inquiry officer’s findings, a hearing at which the accused could present his case, and a final order by the competent authority. The process matters because PEEDA findings, while administrative, carry the weight of the state — the accused had every opportunity to rebut the evidence on record and, according to officials, failed to do so.
The disciplinary action is unusually severe for a posting of this stature:
- Demotion: Sialvi’s service grade has been reduced from BS-19 to BS-18 for a period of five years.
- Transfer: He has been removed from Data Darbar and appointed as a zonal khateeb in Dera Ghazi Khan.
- Lahore ban: He will not be eligible for postings in Lahore or its surrounding areas for five years.
- Shrine ban: The department has further barred him from receiving future postings at any major shrine or mosque.
The department spokesperson did not specify how long the shrine-posting restriction would remain in effect. The department has framed the action as part of an effort to strengthen financial oversight and accountability at Punjab’s religious institutions.
A wider crackdown at the shrine
The khateeb’s demotion is not an isolated case. Data Darbar’s finances have been under intense scrutiny, and the Sialvi ruling follows action against two other former shrine officials.
In a separate departmental proceeding, Punjab Chief Secretary Zahid Akhtar Zaman rejected appeals filed by former Data Darbar administrator Jameel Ahmed and former manager Tahir Maqsood against disciplinary penalties imposed on them over alleged misappropriation and misuse of cash-box collections at the shrine.
The penalties in that case were even steeper. Jameel Ahmed was reduced to a lower post and pay scale for five years, forfeited five years of past service, and was ordered to pay back Rs. 9.266 million. Tahir Maqsood was dismissed from service outright and ordered to pay Rs. 11.325 million.
According to the departmental proceedings, the inquiry found an unusual and sustained decline in cash-box receipts during the previous administration, while collections increased significantly after centralised monitoring was introduced. The investigation also examined allegations involving unauthorised withdrawals and other irregularities. The appellants had argued that the cash boxes were always opened in the presence of the Cash Boxes Committee, but the hearing officer found they had failed to present substantive evidence capable of rebutting the material on record.
The scale of the recoveries — Rs. 9.266 million from one official and Rs. 11.325 million from another — suggests the leakages were not minor lapses but a sustained pattern. For a shrine whose collections fund everything from the langar (free food) for the poor to the upkeep of the centuries-old complex, the figures are sobering.
Why this matters
Data Darbar, the shrine of Hazrat Ali Hajveri (Data Ganj Bakhsh), receives millions of devotees every year and collects substantial donations through its cash boxes — money meant for the upkeep of the shrine, welfare activities and the poor. Allegations that shrine officials were skimming these collections strike at the heart of public trust in one of Pakistan’s most important religious institutions.
Shrine finances across Punjab have long been a sensitive subject, with devotees dropping cash into donation boxes with the assumption that every rupee reaches its intended purpose. The Auqaf Department’s recent actions — demotions, dismissals and multi-million-rupee recoveries — suggest the provincial government is taking that trust seriously.
It is worth noting the distinction in the proceedings so far: the actions against Sialvi, Ahmed and Maqsood are departmental disciplinary findings, not criminal court convictions. The PEEDA inquiry found the charges proven on the administrative record, which is why the penalties are service-related — demotion, dismissal and financial recovery — rather than jail sentences.
What comes next
The Auqaf Department’s centralised monitoring of cash-box collections appears to be working — receipts reportedly rose significantly once the new system was in place, which itself raises questions about how long the leakages had been going on. For now, the message from Lahore is clear: the days of unchecked shrine finances are over, and the province’s custodians of public religious donations will be held to account. Devotees who drop their hard-earned money into Data Darbar’s donation boxes deserve to know it reaches the shrine, the langar and the poor — not the pockets of its keepers.