IMF Urges Pakistan to Drop Costly Fuel Subsidies, Aid Only the Needy

The petrol discount that millions of Pakistani motorcycle and rickshaw riders have been enjoying for the past month is now living on borrowed time. The International Monetary Fund has told Islamabad to phase out its fuel support scheme “promptly”, arguing that the programme costs the national exchequer far too much and hands relief to far too many people — including those who do not need it.

The demand was the one openly contentious point in an otherwise positive statement issued after Pakistan and the IMF reached a staff-level agreement on the latest reviews of the country’s loan programme, unlocking around $1.2 billion in financing once the Fund’s Executive Board approves it.

Key Takeaways

  • The IMF asked Pakistan to phase out its fuel support scheme promptly, citing high cost and broad targeting.
  • The demand came with a staff-level agreement unlocking about $1.2 billion, pending Executive Board approval.
  • Any future fuel aid must be limited, time-bound and routed through established social assistance programmes.

What the IMF Actually Said

An IMF team, led by mission chief Iva Petrova, held discussions with Pakistani authorities on the fourth review under the $7 billion Extended Fund Facility and the third review under the $1.4 billion Resilience and Sustainability Facility in Karachi and Islamabad from September 23 to October 7, 2026.

On the economy, the Fund’s assessment was cautiously upbeat: headline inflation, which peaked in May, had moderated to about 10.3 percent in September, the current account remained broadly balanced on strong workers’ remittances, and gross foreign exchange reserves had risen to approximately $21.5 billion by end-September. Sovereign credit rating upgrades and renewed access to international capital markets, the IMF noted, reflected improved policy credibility.

But buried in the statement was a passage that openly disagreed with government policy: Pakistan, the Fund said, should phase out its fuel support scheme promptly given its high cost and broad targeting. Any future fuel support — should global oil prices surprise on the upside — must be limited, time-bound, targeted at vulnerable households through established social assistance programmes, and absorbed within the FY27 budget envelope.

The Scheme That Worries the Fund

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif announced the fuel relief scheme on September 13, offering Rs100 a litre off petrol for motorcycles, rickshaws and cars up to 800cc. Two- and three-wheelers get the discount on up to 20 litres a month, small cars on up to 30 litres.

Late in September, the petroleum minister said more than six million people had registered and that spending was running at Rs35 billion to Rs40 billion a month — with the scheme potentially running another 10 months at a total cost of Rs400 billion to Rs500 billion.

The numbers behind the headline look stretched. Six million motorcyclists drawing their full 20 litres would cost about Rs12 billion a month — roughly a third of the stated monthly bill. The arithmetic only works if enrolment climbs to 17.5 to 20 million bikes, close to the country’s entire fleet of older motorcycles. That is precisely what the Fund means by “broad targeting”.

At the pump, the effect is dramatic. Petrol was retailing at Rs396.65 a litre after the latest revision, of which Rs114 is taxes and duties. The Rs100 discount cuts the price for an eligible rider by about a quarter, to Rs296.65 — handing back roughly 88 percent of the tax on that litre. When the government gives away nearly the entire tax take on fuel to tens of millions of riders, the fiscal arithmetic collapses.

Why Blanket Subsidies Backfire

The IMF’s objection is not cruelty — it is arithmetic. Broad fuel subsidies suffer from three well-documented problems, and Pakistan’s scheme shows all three:

They cost far more than planned. Enrolment-based schemes expand as word spreads. A programme budgeted for the needy quickly becomes a programme for anyone with a motorcycle — and in Pakistan, that is a very large number of people.

They benefit the better-off too. Fuel consumption rises with income. Owners of multiple bikes, cars just under the 800cc cut-off and commercial riders capture a disproportionate share of a “pro-poor” discount.

They starve better uses of the money. Every rupee spent subsidising petrol for a middle-class car owner is a rupee not spent on schools, hospitals or direct cash support. Notably, the IMF pointed out that Pakistan has begun reversing the long-term decline in health and education spending — combined outlays rose from 2.2 percent of GDP in FY24 to 2.5 percent in FY26, with a government commitment to reach 2.8 percent in FY27. Protecting that progress requires fiscal discipline elsewhere.

What the IMF Wants Instead

The Fund’s prescription is not to abandon the vulnerable — it is to help them directly. Its statement calls for:

  • Prompt phase-out of the current broad fuel scheme, with no further expansion.
  • Targeted, time-bound support if oil prices spike, delivered through established social assistance mechanisms — meaning programmes like the Benazir Income Support Programme, which has beneficiary lists, payment systems and verification infrastructure already in place.
  • Expansion of targeted cash transfers, better beneficiary coverage and more efficient payment systems to protect low-income households from economic shocks.
  • Energy sector reforms continuing alongside: better recovery of outstanding payments, reduction of losses and measures to lower production costs.
  • Fiscal discipline anchored by the FY27 budget’s underlying primary surplus target of 2 percent of GDP, to keep public debt on a sustainable downward path.
  • Tight monetary policy from the State Bank of Pakistan to bring inflation sustainably back toward its target range.

The logic is straightforward: cash in a poor household’s hands does more good than cheap petrol at a pump that the rich also use. A BISP transfer can be targeted, verified and switched off when the crisis passes. A fuel discount cannot.

What This Means for Ordinary Pakistanis

If the government complies — and with $1.2 billion in disbursements on the line, it has strong reason to — the Rs100-a-litre discount will likely wind down in the coming months. For motorcycle riders who budgeted around the Rs296-odd effective price, the return to full pump prices near Rs397 a litre will sting, particularly for delivery riders and daily commuters for whom fuel is a work expense.

The government’s challenge is to make the transition politically survivable: phase the discount out gradually while visibly expanding targeted cash support, so the poorest riders feel the cushion before they feel the price. How that balancing act plays out will be one of the defining economic stories of the winter — and a key test of whether Pakistan can finally break its cycle of announcing broad subsidies it cannot afford.