LESCO Accused of Overbilling Consumers Through Smart Meters

The Lahore Electric Supply Company (LESCO) is facing fresh allegations of overbilling, this time through its advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) smart meters. According to recent media reports, communication with some smart meters was deliberately blocked — effectively muting them — and extra electricity units were then added to consumer bills through adjustments, allegedly to meet internal line-loss targets.

Some consumers reportedly noticed significant discrepancies between the meter readings shown on their bills and the photographic evidence of their meters printed on those same bills. With electricity prices already straining household budgets, the unusually high bills have left many struggling to pay.

Key Takeaways

  • LESCO is accused of blocking communication with AMI smart meters and adding extra units to consumer bills to meet line-loss targets.
  • Some bills reportedly show meter readings that do not match the meter photographs printed on them.
  • The Punjab Assembly speaker has summoned the LESCO chief and promised to raise the matter with the prime minister.

What Is Being Alleged

The core allegation, first reported by Pakistani technology media, is that the communication links of certain AMI smart meters were stopped, rendering the meters silent. While the meters were inactive, billing adjustments were applied that added extra units to consumer accounts. Sources quoted in the reports blamed the practice on unstable line-loss targets set within the company.

Line losses — the difference between electricity supplied into the grid and the electricity actually billed to consumers — are a key performance metric for distribution companies. When actual losses exceed targets, staff face pressure. The allegation is that instead of addressing the root causes of the losses, extra units were simply charged to paying consumers to make the numbers look better.

Meter Photos vs. Bill Readings

One of the most troubling details is the mismatch between printed meter photographs and the billed readings. Modern smart-meter bills carry a photograph of the consumer’s meter. In some cases, the reading printed on the bill reportedly did not match the photograph on the same bill — a discrepancy that consumers could spot for themselves.

Political and Institutional Response

The controversy has reached the Punjab Assembly. Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan chaired a joint meeting of the Law Reforms Committee and Special Committee No. 16, where LESCO chief executive Muhammad Ramzan Butt was questioned over widespread overbilling complaints. Earlier, the speaker had summoned the LESCO chief over the overbilling issue, and according to reports said he would take LESCO complaints to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif.

The speaker has also called for an investigation into LESCO over allegations of overbilling, bribery and misconduct, and said he had discussed the matter with Federal Power Minister Awais Leghari.

A Recurring Pattern

This is not the first time LESCO has faced overbilling accusations. A crackdown was previously launched on the directives of the interior minister, during which the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) took action against LESCO staff. The FIA registered cases against seven LESCO officers, including five sub-divisional officers and two revenue officers, accused of Rs 40 crore in overbilling over two years. LESCO and FIA later reached an agreement to phase out overbilling within three months.

Notably, when the crackdown eliminated overbilling, LESCO’s line-loss rate reportedly rose to around 15 percent — suggesting the earlier, lower figures had been artificially suppressed. Complaints of overbilling resurfaced once the FIA operations concluded, and reports then emerged of extra units being charged to consumers to continuously push line losses down.

The Bigger Picture: Rs 47.81 Billion in Overbilling

The allegations come against the backdrop of a damning audit presented before the Public Accounts Committee (PAC). Audit officials revealed that power distribution companies (DISCOs) overbilled consumers by Rs 47.81 billion in a single month, with 278,649 consumers overcharged due to incorrect meter readings.

According to the audit report, LESCO accounted for approximately Rs 45 billion of that overbilling, while Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO) was responsible for around Rs 1.56 billion. The revelations emerged during a PAC meeting chaired by Shahida Akhtar Ali, reviewing the Power Division’s Audit Report 2024-25.

Officials told the committee that the overbilling was allegedly used to conceal operational inefficiencies as well as transmission and distribution losses. Audit officials further informed the committee that refunds were generally issued only to consumers who challenged inflated bills, and alleged that some lower-level staff used discretionary powers to overbill consumers to offset electricity theft and line losses.

Smart Meters Were Supposed to Fix This

Ironically, smart meters were introduced precisely to prevent such manipulation. During the PAC briefing, Power Division Secretary Dr Fakhray Alam Irfan said the government was deploying smart meters to reduce such incidents. But PAC members questioned the pace of reforms, with Senator Saleem Mandviwalla noting that similar assurances had been made for nearly two decades.

LESCO Starts Printing Meter Reading Dates

Amid the scrutiny, LESCO has begun publishing the scheduled meter reading dates on electricity bills — a move that came as the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) and the FIA launched an inquiry into the company’s failure to include these dates previously. The inclusion of the reading date enables consumers to estimate their units accurately by comparing the specified date with the date and time recorded on the meter photograph.

Investigative teams had highlighted the absence of reading dates on bills, and LESCO could not provide a satisfactory explanation for the omission, according to reports.

What Consumers Can Do

For Lahore consumers facing suspiciously high bills, the steps are clear:

  • Check your meter against the bill: Compare the physical meter reading with the “current reading” printed on your bill, and cross-check the meter photograph printed on the bill itself.
  • File a complaint: LESCO operates a Customer Complaint Management System (CCMS) online, and consumers can call 118 or 0800-00118, or send an SMS to 8118. Billing disputes should be filed under “Billing/Overbilling” with meter photos attached as evidence.
  • Escalate if unresolved: If LESCO does not resolve the complaint in time, consumers can approach NEPRA’s Complaint Management System, which can order refunds or penalties.
  • Challenge inflated bills: Remember that audits have shown refunds generally go only to consumers who challenge inflated bills — silence costs money.

Caveats and Unanswered Questions

Important caveats apply. The smart-meter allegations have not been confirmed by LESCO’s own meter data, a NEPRA ruling, or an official investigation, and no figures exist for the number of meters or units involved. The reports reviewed did not include a LESCO response to the claims.

The episode underlines a hard truth about Pakistan’s power sector: technology alone cannot fix governance. Smart meters can record consumption accurately, but if billing staff work around them, the fraud simply moves to a new venue. For LESCO’s consumers in Lahore, Okara, Sheikhupura, Nankana Sahib and Kasur, the lesson is practical: photograph your meter, check your bill, and challenge anything that does not add up.