The Islamabad High Court has asked the federal government to account for more than 50 Pakistanis who went missing after leaving the country through irregular channels in search of work, in a case that has reopened national attention on the dangers of unsafe migration routes.
Hearing a petition filed by families of the missing men, Justice Arbab Muhammad Tahir directed the assistant attorney general to look into the matter and submit a detailed report before the next hearing on November 2. The court also issued formal notices to the federal government.
Key Takeaways
- The IHC has directed the federal government to trace more than 50 Pakistanis missing after boat journeys from Mauritania to Spain.
- Families of youths from Punjab say they lost all contact between April 2024 and January 2025 and received no official update.
- The court will hear the case again on November 2 after reviewing the government’s report.
What the families told the court
The petition was filed by Afzal Hussain Shah, a resident of Phalia in the Mandi Bahauddin district of Punjab, and argued by Advocate Shafqat Abbas Tarar. According to the petition, more than 50 young men from Mandi Bahauddin, Gujranwala, Gujrat, Hafizabad and adjoining areas travelled out of Pakistan over the last three years through unofficial routes and have not been traced since.
The counsel told the court that many of the youths had attempted the perilous Atlantic crossing: they reportedly boarded boats from Mauritania in West Africa, heading toward Spain. Those journeys took place between April 2024 and January 2025, but the men never reached their destination.
Their families, the court was informed, have not received any reliable information about the men’s whereabouts or immigration status in any country. Before approaching the judiciary, the petitioner had already sent written requests to the prime minister, the foreign minister and the interior minister — but says no concrete action followed.
What the court has been asked to do
The petitioner’s lawyer asked the court to direct the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to conduct consular inquiries in the countries where the missing men are believed to have travelled, and to use Pakistani embassies and consulates to trace them.
He also asked for immigration and travel records to be examined, so the authorities can establish exactly how the men left Pakistan and where they went. If the inquiries point to criminal activity — such as organised human smuggling — he requested that legal action be taken. And he urged the state to make arrangements for the safe return of any of the men found alive abroad.
The court was further asked to have the authorities determine whether the missing citizens might be stranded somewhere, detained, deported or held in some other status that their families simply have not been told about.
Justice Tahir called the assistant attorney general to the rostrum during the hearing, directed him to examine the whole matter, and adjourned proceedings until November 2.
A familiar and dangerous route
The Mauritania-to-Spain crossing is one of the most dangerous migration routes in the world. Small boats departing the West African coast aim for Spain’s Canary Islands, crossing hundreds of kilometres of open Atlantic water. International reporting has repeatedly documented drownings and disappearances on this route, including incidents involving Pakistani nationals.
The issue is not new for Pakistan. In early 2025, a boat carrying migrants — including dozens of Pakistanis — sank off the coast of Morocco, drawing grief and condemnation from across the country and prompting renewed pledges from authorities to crack down on human smugglers.
Why this case matters
Irregular migration remains a persistent problem in Punjab’s central districts, where overseas employment is often seen as the surest path out of economic hardship. Agents promise passage to Europe through convoluted routes — first flying to Africa or the Middle East, then attempting sea crossings — for fees that can run into millions of rupees.
The families in this case allege that their sons were taken along exactly such a chain. The court’s involvement now puts pressure on the foreign ministry and overseas missions to produce answers: who left, through which route, and what happened to them.
For the families, the November 2 report could be the first official account of what the state knows about their missing sons — or a confirmation of how little has been done so far.
What happens next
The assistant attorney general must report back at the next hearing. Legal experts say the court’s notices to the federal government are a standard but serious step: they compel ministries to file written responses and open the door to further directions — including instructions to foreign missions — if the report is found wanting.
Beyond this case, the proceedings highlight a wider policy question. Pakistan has anti-trafficking laws and has periodically announced crackdowns on human smuggling networks, yet young men continue to disappear on routes like the Mauritania crossing. Whether judicial pressure translates into sustained action against smugglers and better protection for potential migrants remains to be seen.
For now, the families of more than 50 missing Pakistanis wait for November 2 — hoping that this time, the state will have answers.