Israel has ordered foreign airlines to stop assigning pilots and cabin crew who hold the nationality — including as a second nationality — of 29 countries without formal diplomatic relations with the country. Since most of those countries are Muslim-majority, including Pakistan, the directive in practice sidelines thousands of Muslim dual nationals from working flights to Tel Aviv, even if their other passport is American, French, or British.
This is not a ban on all Muslim travelers entering Israel. It is a crew-scheduling rule aimed at who can fly aircraft into Israeli airspace. But its reach is wide, and for affected airline employees, the message is blunt: a second passport from the “wrong” country now disqualifies you.
Key Takeaways
- Israel now bars airline crew who hold citizenship or dual nationality from 29 countries without diplomatic relations with Israel from flights entering its airspace.
- United Airlines and Air France have begun enforcing the rule, pulling affected pilots and cabin crew from Tel Aviv routes.
- The move follows the September 30 cockpit attack on flydubai flight FZ1073, allegedly carried out by an Omani first officer who had previously flown to Tel Aviv twice.
What the New Directive Says
According to an internal United Airlines memo shared with the aviation outlet Live and Let’s Fly, Israeli authorities have issued updated requirements covering the nationality and dual citizenship of crew members on flights entering Israeli airspace. The rule states that crew who hold citizenship or dual nationality from certain countries that do not maintain formal diplomatic relations with Israel may not operate or even be onboard these flights.
Crucially, the restriction is about citizenship — not birthplace, not residence, and not religion. A flight attendant who was born in New York, holds a US passport, and has never set foot in Iran is still barred if they also hold Iranian citizenship. United has told affected employees to contact crew scheduling to be reassigned, and says it is building the restriction into its planning systems.
The memo lists 29 countries. They are:
- Afghanistan, Algeria, Bangladesh, Brunei, Comoros, Djibouti
- Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Malaysia, Maldives, Mali, Mauritania, Niger
- Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, Tunisia, Yemen
- Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela
All but three of them — Cuba, North Korea, and Venezuela — are Muslim-majority states. Some outlets have reported slightly different list sizes (31 or 27 countries), so the exact final count may still be shifting.
Airlines Are Already Enforcing It
The directive is not just theoretical. United Airlines has already begun implementing it for its Tel Aviv flights, with scheduling alerts going out to crews this past weekend. Air France has also told some employees they can no longer work Israel flights, according to the Israeli public broadcaster KAN — and the airline has reportedly warned staff to disclose any second nationality, cautioning that non-compliance could lead to disciplinary action.
Enforcement may expose Air France to legal challenges in France, where workplace discrimination law is strict. The rule also raises unresolved practical questions: how airlines must transmit crew nationality data to Israeli authorities, and what penalties they face for getting it wrong.
Israel is reportedly also developing an electronic pre-clearance system to review crew and passenger data 24 to 48 hours before departure — a sign the memo-driven approach may be just the first step.
Why Now: The Flydubai Cockpit Attack
The trigger is the September 30 incident aboard flydubai flight FZ1073, traveling from Dubai to Tel Aviv, in which Omani first officer Hamam al-Hammami allegedly attacked captain Smit Machchhar with a crash axe and tried to crash the packed airliner into the Ben Gurion terminal. The Boeing 737 plunged more than 14,000 feet in under 30 seconds before passengers and off-duty pilots rushed the cockpit, overpowered the attacker, and landed safely in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. The UAE has described it as an attempted terrorist act.
The security fallout in Israel has been severe. Israeli media reported that al-Hammami had already operated two previous flights to Tel Aviv without incident. Oman has no diplomatic relations with Israel and did not join the Abraham Accords. Channel 12 reported that the Shin Bet had effectively left enforcement of the existing restriction to foreign airlines and had not independently verified crew origins. Prime Minister Netanyahu has now ordered a sweeping review of aviation security arrangements for foreign flights, examining the roles of the Transportation Ministry, Civil Aviation Authority, Shin Bet, and Mossad.
In short: a ban on aircrew from countries without diplomatic ties supposedly existed for years, but was never enforced. The flydubai attack proved that — and Israel’s response has been to tighten the net to include dual nationals.
What This Means for Pakistani Readers
Pakistan is on the list. That matters less for PIA — Pakistan has no direct flights to Israel and no diplomatic relations with it — and more for Pakistani-origin pilots, engineers, and cabin crew working abroad for Gulf, European, and American carriers that operate Tel Aviv routes.
A pilot with both a Pakistani and a British passport, for instance, employed by a Gulf airline, can no longer be rostered on Israel flights under these rules, regardless of which passport they travel on or where they actually live. The same applies to dual nationals from Bangladesh, Indonesia, Malaysia, and other countries with large expatriate aviation workforces in the Gulf.
It also applies to transit: the restriction reportedly covers flights merely passing through Israeli airspace, not just those landing at Ben Gurion Airport, which could complicate route planning for carriers operating in the region.
The Honest Caveats
A few things to keep straight:- This is not officially a “Muslim ban.” The stated criterion is diplomatic relations, not religion. Cuba, North Korea, and Venezuela are on the list too. But the practical effect overwhelmingly falls on nationals of Muslim-majority countries.
- It targets crew, not all travelers. There is no new evidence that ordinary tourists or visitors with dual nationality are affected.
- The list may still change. United’s memo names 29 countries and cautions it may not be exhaustive; other outlets have cited different numbers.
- Existing policy vs. new policy. Israeli officials say some version of this restriction existed before; what is new is active enforcement and the extension to dual citizens and cabin crew.
Conclusion
Whether you call it a security measure or a de facto nationality ban, the effect is the same: thousands of airline crew members — mostly Muslim dual nationals — are being pulled off Israel flights based on a second passport, not anything they have done. The flydubai cockpit attack gave Israel the justification; the question now is how far the restriction goes, whether airlines can legally comply, and whether pre-clearance will extend the same scrutiny from cockpit crews to ordinary passengers. For Pakistani aviation professionals working in the Gulf and beyond, it is a rule worth knowing before you check the roster.