The University of Karachi has removed its Controller of Examinations following explosive revelations that more than 150 failed law students were declared successful through an irregular scrutiny process — a controversy that has raised serious questions about the integrity of one of Pakistan’s largest public universities.
The university has appointed Associate Professor Dr Syed Ghufran of the Department of Food Science as the new Controller of Examinations, replacing Dr Yasir, according to ARY News, which first reported the story on 9 October 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Karachi University removed its Controller of Examinations after reports that 150+ failed law students were declared passed.
- The scrutiny process that changed the results allegedly violated university rules, which allow only recounting, not rechecking.
- The outgoing controller denies any wrongdoing; no formal inquiry committee has been constituted yet.
What Happened
According to media reports, more than 150 students from affiliated law colleges — SM Law College and Islamia Law College — had initially failed two subjects in the announced BA/LLB examination results. They were later declared successful after a special scrutiny process approved during the two-month tenure of former acting Vice Chancellor Tufail Jokhio.
The process began when the dean of the Faculty of Law submitted a written recommendation seeking scrutiny of students’ results. The examination department acted on that recommendation with the acting vice chancellor’s approval, and a scrutiny committee cleared the students in subjects they had previously failed.
Reports from local media, including published copies of answer sheets and mark sheets, allege that many students moved from fail to pass — with some answer sheets reportedly found blank yet carrying marks. The university’s new permanent vice chancellor, Dr Wasim Qazi, reportedly reviewed the papers and confirmed that anomaly to reporters.
Why the Scrutiny Was Irregular
The controversy hinges on what university rules actually allow:
- Individual applications required: Scrutiny rules require students to submit individual applications — not collective petitions from colleges.
- Recounting, not rechecking: Under the annual examination system, scrutiny generally permits only a recounting of marks, not a full rechecking or reassessment of answer scripts.
- A prior halt: Former permanent Vice Chancellor Dr Khalid Iraqi had previously refused to process the collective student request on exactly these grounds, pointing out that the bylaws did not permit it.
Result.pk’s reporting added that the disputed grade revisions were approved after a committee meeting on August 5 that reviewed a specific LLB Part II paper, with approval secured the following day — and that flexible phrasing in the committee’s minutes was allegedly used to extend grade adjustments to other subjects like Pakistan Studies.
The Other Side
Former Controller of Examinations Dr Yasir has denied that any students were passed or failed through the process, declining to comment further. SM Law College’s principal defended the intervention, arguing that a large cohort of students had been failed unfairly by a single teacher, making institutional relief necessary.
No formal independent inquiry or forensic audit has been announced as of publication. University officials have warned that delays in opening a probe risk the loss or tampering of physical evidence — the answer sheets themselves.
Why It Matters
The University of Karachi affiliates dozens of professional colleges across Sindh, and its LLB results determine who enters Pakistan’s legal profession. For thousands of candidates who prepare for years to earn their degrees honestly, the suspicion that a scrutiny committee converted failures into passes undermines the value of every legitimate certificate.
The controversy also sits uncomfortably next to the government’s digitization push — paper-based answer sheets and opaque scrutiny committees are exactly the conditions where irregularities thrive.
What Needs to Happen
Stakeholders, including academics and students, are calling for a transparent inquiry with an independent audit of the disputed answer scripts. Until the university constitutes a formal probe and publishes its findings, the cloud over these 150-plus results — and over the university’s examination system as a whole — will not lift.
Conclusion
Whether the scrutiny committee acted on genuine grievances about unfair marking or crossed the line into result manipulation is now for a proper inquiry to determine. What is clear is that the University of Karachi has chosen to remove its exams chief first and answer questions later — a signal that the institution itself recognizes how seriously its credibility has been damaged.
The Bigger Picture: Affiliated Colleges and Oversight
The University of Karachi does not just examine its own students — it affiliates dozens of private and public colleges across Sindh, including law colleges like SM Law College and Islamia Law College, whose students sit for university-conducted examinations. That makes the exams department one of the most consequential offices in the province’s higher education system: its results decide who graduates, who practices law, and whose degree employers trust.
Because affiliated colleges pay affiliation fees and depend on the university for examinations, the relationship has always carried the risk of pressure from colleges on the exams machinery. This is not the first time a Pakistani public university has faced allegations of result tampering — but the scale alleged here, more than 150 students, is unusually large.
The controversy also raises questions for the Higher Education Commission and the Sindh government about oversight of examination departments. Answer sheets that are reportedly blank yet carry marks point to a failure not just of procedure but of basic record-keeping — the kind of failure that a digitized, auditable examination system could make much harder to repeat.
What Students Affected Should Know
For the students whose results were changed, uncertainty now surrounds their status. If an inquiry reverses the scrutiny decisions, some could see their results reverted to fail — with consequences for their academic years and professional futures. The university has a duty to clarify their position quickly and transparently, whatever the inquiry finds.
Conclusion
The University of Karachi is one of Pakistan’s flagship public universities, and its degrees carry weight far beyond Karachi. Restoring trust will take more than a personnel change — it will take a public, independent inquiry and published findings. Until then, every result the examinations department issues will carry a question mark it cannot afford.